You are not wrong wrong. The major underlying problem here is the social attitude of the players on this server and forums where everybody wants the swollen population down by any means necessary including the mass banning of players (like the Chinese witch hunt currently ongoing) whether 100% proved guilty or not, until it happens to them. They are self serving individuals only thinking about themselves and the lag they experience and think that denying others the experience of this server to help alleviate their lag problems so they can get back to farming is appropriate action to take. Like this dumb post for example but there are countless :
http://forum.nostalrius.org/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=34793There was definitely win trading going on via empty games. I know because I qued into and got stuck in them on alliance side several times versus the chinese horde premade. However, I highly doubt everybody present was in on it. But since there would be no way to know which players exactly were behind it as they were probably using voice chat or some outside chat program and not in-game chat which would be logged and easily tracked, they just banned everybody there.
Mjl is a perfect example of someone who was falsely banned of win trading without evidence (other than circumstance) because he happened to be in that game. He wasn't even in their premade, he solo queued into it and still was banned. It sure seems like they are trigger happy with the ban hammer just to try and cull the population and righting their wrongs and unlocking the accounts of people who were mistakenly banned is clearly not high on their priority list with all the stuff going on plus high population being a problem anyways. So be it. I'm sure everybody here will be on board with this until they are victimized by it themselves then they will be in here singing the same sad tune.
inb4 salty - Yes I am mad for still being banned when I am clearly innocent, it reeeeeaaally sucks, and you would be salty too.