Ohhgee wrote:Ohhgee wrote:Blizzlike queues + No Multiqueue = the "best" Premade controls the top standings.
Ok, so:
Let's call A the "best" premade and B a random premade, both on same faction. Let's call (Ci) a family of random premades on the opposite faction.
And be E the current q system, and F the one you suggest.
Let's say A is defined by the fact they consistently beat any of the (Ci). While B has difficulties against the (Ci).
Now I'm going to give the likely scenarios in E and F:
Let's first look at what happens in E.
If there is enough (Ci), both A and B are systematically matched against a (Ci).
If there is enough (Ci), both A and B have faster qs than a regular pug.
What happens to A?
A is winning most of his games and some of them are even very fast wins: he gains fast honnor overall (faster than pug that face long qs and higher loss ratio).
Some Ci may even start scouting in order to dodge A.
So some of the games A is having will be against pugs, resulting in even faster honnor.
What happens to B?
B is struggling and have about the same win/loss ratio than a pug.
The Ci are less likely to dodge B.
B is less likely to be matched against pugs than A.
B may even want to dodge some of the Ci. And doing that they lose the advantage of their fast qs... and will be matched against another Ci the next game.
In E, it's clear that A has an advantage over B.
Now what happens in F?
A and B has the same win ratio, since they are both matched against pugs.
B can dodge as much as he wants if he faces a Ci : he's not losing the fast q advantage that doesn't exist to begin with, and he has a high chance to face a pug rather than another Ci the next game.
If B dodge effectively, but A decides to fight against the Ci, then A will start losing honor.
The two outcome are either A starting dodging or A being less honnor effective than B.
In F, A has no advantage whatsoever on B.
It's
exactly what is happening.
Last warsong we: Niko's premade dominated and won every single prem v prem game. Monday, all the alliance premade started either dodging or going for HK farm ratehr than BG win. Niko's premade was the "best" premade that week and made faster honnor than any other ranker.
This AB we: Alliance premades are dominating and none of the horde is even willing to form a premade / fight them back.
Alliance being the only faction to currently be able to premade against pug is a direct consequence of them dominating a scaring horde away from premading.
Just as Niko's premade getting pug games last warsong weekend was a direct consequence of his group dominating.
In the current system, you don't get free honnor games just by having a premade. You need to beat the other faction's premade first. You need to dominate, then you're entitled to your reward.
If you're unable to do that, then there is no reason you'd be entitled to a faster honnor/hour gain.
If you can put together the "best" premade, then you do it and collect your candies after scaring the opposite faction away. This will give you the best standings, simple as that.
If you can't, then why would you have the best standings?